Writing is a subversive act. This is the essential thesis of Richard Flanagan’s essays in a collection called Heresies: Occasional Pieces (Penguin, 2026).
It’s a powerful tome. I have found I can only read a bit of it at a time. The style is dense and easily depressing, as it engages unrelentingly with so many of the challenges of our time, and with prophetic challenge. Flanagan really is a great wordsmith and an equally insistent truth-teller: a prophet. He refuses to peddle the half-truths or convenient lies of our current body politic, in relation to colonial invasion, climate change, and environmental destruction, our horrific treatment of asylum seekers, and many other matters.
Ten years ago he delivered a lecture on the theme ‘Does Writing Matter?‘ Here he addressed the hideous, morally bankrupt behaviour of Australian Governments, with the acquiescence of the voting public, in detention of asylum seekers, both on- and off-shore. He draws upon Camus’ novel The Plague, and I will quote his insights:
We in Australia were well contented. But now the rats are among us; the plague is upon us; and each of us must choose whether we are with the plague or against it.
A solidarity of the silenced, a resistance of the shaken, starts with what Camus understood was the necessity of weighing our words, by calling things their proper names, and knowing that not doing so leads to the death and suffering of many.
It is by naming cruelty as cruelty, evil as evil, the plague as plague.
He goes on:
The role of the writer in one sense is the very real struggle to keep words alive, to restore to them their proper meaning and necessary dignity as the means by which we divine truth. In this battle the writer is doomed to fail, but the battle is no less important. The war is only lost when language ceases to serve its most fundamental purpose, and that only happens when we are persuaded that writing no longer matters. … But even when we are silenced we must continue to write. To assert freedom. To find meaning. …Because writing matters. More than ever, it matters. (emphasis mine)
In a later essay, Flanagan explains that our response to this crisis is to offer some heresies. The word has a long history in religious and political circles. It implies the power of those who define what is acceptable, right, true, and labels other views as wrong, or heretical.
Heretics have been seen as weird, mad, or bad, due to their unwillingness to fit in, conform, accept the established way of living, believing, acting, worshipping, and so forth.
But we owe a great deal to those who insisted on their heretical ideas, in science, medicine, ethics, and political philosophy. The same is true for those heretics who fought (and died) for freedom of religion and the rights of every human being.
Interestingly, one of the very earliest meanings of the Greek root for the word heresy is choice. It means an alternative, a different way of seeing or being. It asserts freedom.
I deeply appreciate Flanagan’s ideas. They affirm why we should write. Why I should write.
Such writing is never only for oneself, though it is an act of self-expression and self-affirmation. It is an instance of ‘Here I stand‘:
I stand, rather than cower.
I stand, and will not censor myself.
I stand, willing to be counted for something.
I stand, inviting others to join me.
In this way, writing is a social act—an act of social formation, inviting response, perhaps agreement or disagreement, further consideration and refinement.
Flanagan’s idea of heresy involves these dimensions of choice, standing against all that would entertain us into silent submission.
Heretical writing invites us to be done with ‘likes’: instead to act, beginning perhaps with speaking to another human being.
And in doing so, we oppose other heresies, such as the absurd assertion of the richest man in the world, that empathy is ‘the fundamental weakness of Western civilisation’. Against this, I assert the heresy of love, in all its forms, as the fundamental strength of humanity. Full stop.
The Christian story began this way—subversive speaking and writing and living, together, until the Empire took control and formal doctrines replaced the powerful heresies Jesus lived and taught.
But they’ve never entirely silenced it.
He just won’t stay dead!
What do you say?
What heresies do you affirm?